In spots, Canal 116 on North Plantation Key once dropped to 17 feet. When the village redesigned the canal's restoration in 2023, it set the target depth at 7.6 feet below mean lower low water, according to Keys Weekly's account of that council meeting. The canal is now finished, and its bottom is growing seagrass. That outcome matters to anyone comparing canal homes in Islamorada.
The village improves a stagnant canal mainly by raising its bottom. Water quality and depth now trade against each other on the public record, one canal at a time. If you're shopping for a canal home in Islamorada, find out where the canal sits in that process, because the depth in a listing today may be a starting point the village plans to change.
The method goes back to a demonstration program that Monroe County, Islamorada and the City of Marathon completed in 2014. It tested five canal restoration techniques: backfilling, weed gates and air curtains, culverts, organic removal and aeration. Florida International University monitored the results. As the village's engineering consultant WSP summarized them in an April 2026 proposal, FIU concluded that "for deep canals, water quality in residential canals cannot be improved without reducing canal depth," and it recommended raising canal bottoms to shallower than about 7 feet.
The same study found that air curtains and weed gates kept seaweed out of canals. Canals that got only a weed barrier showed no improvement in water quality. So a canal with a working air curtain at its mouth can look clean at the surface and still have poor water underneath.
The problem is large. The 2013 Monroe County Canal Management Master Plan evaluated 500 canals across the Florida Keys and rated more than 300 of them fair or poor, according to the state's 2024 Florida Keys annual report.
Canal 116 runs between Ocean Drive and Plantation Drive on North Plantation Key. It was the first canal in Islamorada proposed for backfilling, and the village's canal ranking listed it with the poorest water quality, Keys Weekly reported in March 2023. The original design called for a depth of 6 feet at mean lower low water. A revision to 7.6 feet needed less fill and cut $466,235 from the cost.
Depth for larger boats was the main question raised at that meeting, along with whether to fill only the deepest holes instead of the whole canal. Peter Frezza, the village's environmental resources manager, answered that reducing the backfill to leave more depth would not improve overall water quality. He also cited the six backfilled canals Monroe County had completed in the Upper Keys: "I haven't heard any reports from engineers, county staff or residents that there have been any impediments to navigation in the canal because of the backfill." Council members wanted more confidence that most of the neighborhood supported the plan, and the council tabled the contractor selection that night.
The council approved the project later in 2023. According to Keys Weekly's January 2025 follow-up, Tavernier-based Adventure Environmental did the $1.3 million backfill, and the work was finished by January 2024. Before the project, the canal had very low oxygen, high turbidity and almost nothing growing on the bottom. Within a year of completion, seagrass and macroalgae covered about half the bottom. Shoal grass, turtle grass and six species of macroalgae had moved in, ten fish species had been observed, and starlet coral was growing. Consultants continue to monitor the canal twice a year.
The state's 2024 report breaks down the cost: $64,085 for design and permitting, $1,348,903 for construction and $69,110 for monitoring, funded through a Florida Keys Stewardship Act grant. Owners on Canal 116 got a clean canal paid for largely with state money, and in exchange the canal is shallower.
The next canal in line is also on Plantation Key. On October 6, 2026, the Village Council approved Work Authorization No. 4 with WSP, for up to $80,249.31, to carry the Canal 119 backfilling project through feasibility, data collection, design, permitting and bid support. The money is in the FY 2026-2027 capital budget.
WSP's proposal says the canal's homeowners have already installed an air curtain at the canal mouth. In WSP's words, an air curtain "is good at keeping future sargassum out of the canal, but will not correct the other issues causing water quality degradation, including organic accumulation and deep pockets." The preliminary concept is to backfill the entire canal to 6 feet below mean lower low water. Depending on how much muck the survey finds, the organic sediment would be removed first, capped, or both, and the existing air curtain would likely stay as it is.
Six feet was also Canal 116's original design depth before the village revised it to 7.6 feet in 2023. For Canal 119, it is still a concept. WSP's scope calls for a survey-grade bathymetric survey of the canal bottom, certified-mail letters to every property owner on the canal, and one neighborhood public meeting. A homeowner's property with a boat ramp is being evaluated as a possible staging area for equipment. Final plans and the engineer's construction cost estimate come after the survey and permitting meetings. If you're considering a home on Canal 119, the depth in its final design is the figure to watch for.
Canal 116 and Canal 119 are part of a longer list. The state's 2024 report, current as of September 2024, credited Islamorada with seven completed canal projects and three underway. Several used lighter methods than backfilling.
| Canal | Method | Status and date |
|---|---|---|
| 116, North Plantation Key | Backfill | Completed January 2024 |
| 119, Plantation Key | Backfill, 6-ft concept | WSP design and permitting work authorized, October 2026 |
| 145, Lower Matecumbe, Atlantic side | Organic removal and backfill | Proposals due July 7, 2026; inspection services on the September 8, 2026 agenda |
| 114 | Injection well | Listed complete, September 2024 report |
| 118 | Organic debris removal | Listed complete, September 2024 report |
| 132, 137, 148 | Debris barrier | Listed complete, September 2024 report; homeowners paid for 132 |
Canal 145 runs between Columbus Drive and Cortez Drive. Its scope includes temporarily removing the existing air curtain and reinstalling it after the backfill. Nearby on Lower Matecumbe, the village is also connecting dead-end canals with culverts. Keys Weekly reported in January 2026 that construction had begun on an $8.9 million project to connect Canals 155 and 157 beneath Sandy Cove Avenue. Our earlier look at what the Safety Harbor canals buy you covers how those culverts affect that neighborhood.
On a Keys listing, "deep water" describes how big a boat the canal can float. The village's program puts a second number beside that one: a depth that restores water quality, which FIU's findings place at less than about 7 feet. On the canals that rank worst, the village is moving the bottom toward that second number. The tradeoff runs both ways. A deep, stagnant canal can carry a larger hull. A restored canal at 6 to 7.6 feet has had its bottom come back to life, as Canal 116 did within a year.
What matters is how your boat fits the target depth. A boat drawing 5 feet on a canal designed to 6 feet has about a foot of water under it at mean lower low water, and the same boat on a 7.6-foot design has more than two and a half. If you're buying for a specific boat, find out where the canal falls in the village's restoration sequence, whether a bathymetric survey has been done, and what depth any design proposes. These questions belong beside the usual ones about bridge clearance and depth at the canal mouth that we covered in our Venetian Shores canal guide.
Sellers have something to show as well. Canal 116 now has a published record of seagrass, ten fish species and starlet coral, and a buyer touring a home there can see the cleaner water for themselves.
Does backfilling make a canal unusable for boats? The village set Canal 116's design depth at 7.6 feet at mean lower low water. In 2023, Peter Frezza reported no navigation problems from the six backfilled canals Monroe County had completed in the Upper Keys. Whether a canal works for you depends on your boat's draft compared with the final design depth.
How many canals does Islamorada have? In 2023, Frezza told the council, "We have 64 canals." Projects so far range from homeowner-funded debris barriers to full backfills.
Who pays for a backfill? On Canal 116, a Florida Keys Stewardship Act grant covered the design, construction and monitoring. Canal 119's design work comes from the village's capital fund.
If you're weighing a canal home on Plantation Key or Lower Matecumbe and want to know where that canal stands in the village's restoration plans and what that means for your boat, Alina Davis would be glad to go through those details with you before you write an offer or set a list price. Let's Connect.
Whether you're searching for your perfect Keys escape, investing in a vacation rental, or selling a slice of paradise you've loved for years, my goal is always the same: honest guidance, strong advocacy, and a seamless experience from start to finish. The Florida Keys isn't just real estate — it's a lifestyle, and I'm here to help you find your place in it. I would be honored to help you take that next step toward sun, water, and everything the Keys has to offer.